Care to Comment?

Now that you've had some time to practice writing blog posts, it's time, yet again, to step up our blogging!  As I mentioned before, a crucial part of participating in the blogosphere is interaction.  It's all about the conversation.  Today, we're going to explain a little more about what this means by introducing you to the blog comment.

A good, thoughtful blog comment might:

• praise interesting ideas in the original post
• ask for clarification of any unclear parts of the original post
• add the responder's own thoughts to original ideas to build strength
• contradict or challenge (respectfully!) by explaining another aspect or asking a question to further dialogue
• contain connections (to the self, the world, another text, or another part of the same text) to deepen thinking about the post

AND good, thoughtful blog responses always

• are respectful and coherent
• use standard vocab, spelling, and grammar (so that everyone can understand)
• show consideration of the original blogger's work and thought

Finally, since blogs are conversations, it's rude not to reply when spoken to!  You are required to comment on at least two separate posts per week.  If you're the original author, you should also reply to comments that you receive.

For some mentor texts on commenting, click on these links to see last year's 8th graders rocking the comments thread:

Pia's post on the painting "Life and Death" by Gustav Klimt

Izzy's post on street art by Banksy (speaking of street art, see Max and Rafaele as well)

Nina's post on how girls and boys respond differently to books

So, let's get talking! 

(Adapted from posts by Ms. Rear and Ms. Robbins and borrowed from Ms. Langbein)

There's a First Time for Everything

Hey 708, 805, and 809!

I have a confession to make: THIS is my first blog post ever.

That being said, I can't say I joined the world of blogging easily--actually there was probably a lot of kicking and screaming going on (mostly metaphoric, of course). You can ask anyone in the 8th grade ELA department--they'll tell you it's true. Unfortunately, I'm kind of new to all of this 21st century technology (I bought my first cell phone just this past March) and it makes teaching with it a little scary for me. Luckily we have Ms. Langbein to help us get this community of bloggers up and running (thanks Ms. Langbein!).

So here it goes. I REALLY thought I was going to hate this. BUT, as it turns out, I really kind of like it. I've read some of your blog posts and it makes me excited to see how stoked you are to start blogging. I LOVE that some of you are asking questions about your fellow blogger's posts that will truly make them think more about their writing and I think it's really fun to sit here on my couch with my laptop and read about what's going on with your reading.

As far as who I am as a reader...mmm....it's hard to say. I love to read a lot of different kinds of texts. During the school year I read a lot of professional books (that probably wouldn't interest you) as well as the books that I see you guys reading (it helps me to understand what's going on in your teenage noggins). Outside of school it's a mixed bag. I like to research random topics because I hate it when I don't know the answer to something. I also read comic books, political commentary, stuff I find on the sidewalk (NYC is great for finding books on the sidewalk!), books and articles about travel, and stuff that friends recommend. I just bought a new book yesterday called MetaMaus by Art Spiegelman and I can't wait to crack it open (and blog about it).

So...here we go! I'm truly looking forward to finding out where all of this blogging about books takes us. I'm thinking it's going to be pretty cool.

Ms. Cunningham

Dangerous Pie, Dangerous Book

Okay, I'll admit it.  When I read Drums, Girls, and Dangerous Pie by Jordan Sonnenblick, there might have been some moments when I teared up a bit.  There might also have been moments when I had to put the book down and get a tissue. 

Specifically, I'm referring to the chapter called "The Fat Cat Sat."  Steven seems confused and in pain in this chapter.  He seems to use anger and his acerbic (ooh, good vocab word!) sense of humor to deal with Jeffery's cancer diagnosis.  He sounds really angry and sarcastic, but I actually think this is a mask for other feelings.  I think he feels scared and guilty.  Since Steven is Jeffery's "Protector," it really bothers Steven that he couldn't "save" his little brother.  I think this because on page 41, Steven says: "But for some reason on that first horrible night, it seemed as though everything I ever did to Jeffery had probably caused some horrible genetic damage."

I felt a lot of sympathy for Steven when I read this quote on page 44: "When [Mom] told me that [Jeffery] would have to go with her to the big city in the morning to see another doctor, all he had asked was, 'Will Steven come, too?'  This was the one piece of information that put me over the edge.  I started crying..."

Me, too.

I deeply identified with Steven's emotions in this chapter.  When he talks about the excitement and then the let-down of experiencing Jeffery's being born, I knew exactly what he meant.  I experienced the same thing, too, when my younger brother was born.  Like Steven, I've also always felt like my brother's Protector.  And like Jeffery, my brother has always idolized me.  In some ways, I have not always been able to be my brother's Protector.  I feel sad and a little guilty about this.  I think Steven probably feels the same way.  It's hard when relationships change.  I hope Steven can come to terms with Jeffery's cancer, and that their relationship becomes stronger, even if it does change.

Intro

Hi!

This is Jessica (otherwise known as Ms. Langbein.)  Thanks for stopping by.

This post is my first endeavor towards entering the world of blogging...in this classroom, at least.  I love blogs.  I've kept a few myself and read blogs constantly, practically everyday.  I like that I can easily access a wide variety of "experts" on any topic.  I like that I can reach out to those experts, ask them questions, engage in discussion, and read the discussions of other members in my online community.  Blogging helps me feel like I belong somewhere.

Outside of the blogosphere, I enjoy reading a wide variety of things.  My favorite author is Jane Austen, and I like fiction often referred to as "chick lit" or "women's fiction," although I despise these terms.  I read a lot of modern Japanese fiction.  I also like memoir and other narrative non-fiction.  Also, I love reading cookbooks.  (Betcha didn't know you could read cookbooks for pleasure, huh?  It's the first section I visit in the bookstore.)  But, lately, it feels like I've been reading nothing but "teacher books:" books on what to teach and how to teach it.

What about you?  What do you like to read?